By Johnathan Paoli

Sibanye-Stillwater has underscored the urgent need for the country to prioritise skills development as a cornerstone for economic growth.

The company’s stakeholder relations executive vice president Thabisile Phumo highlighted the stark contrast between South Africa and countries like China, where vocational training was often seen as a first choice rather than a fallback option.

She was speaking at the Skills Development Dialogue under the theme: “Reimagining Education for a Better Future”, hosted by Sibanye-Stillwater and Inside Education at the University of Johannesburg on Thursday.

“In China, people become artisans not as a plan B, but as a first option because they understand the value of skills. We have to know that economies are built by skills,” she said.

Phumo stressed the need of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges in addressing this crisis.

“There is space for university education, but there is an even bigger space for TVET education because we are a country in crisis,” she said.

Phumo proposed the implementation of quotas for gifted learners from matric to enrol in TVET colleges, emphasising that this approach could significantly alleviate the skills shortage that plagued various sectors, including engineering, healthcare and information technology.

“May our children aspire to be artisans. May they see the value of skills that can be used here and beyond,” she said.

The event, which aimed to explore the integration of skills-based learning into the education system from early childhood, reflected a broader government initiative to prioritise TVET education.

With limited access to traditional university pathways for many South Africans, TVET colleges represented a viable alternative for skills development, fostering pathways to gainful employment and economic stability.

Phumo noted the potential benefits of a more skilled workforce, and said the positive ripple effects of an approach focused on skills extended beyond economic benefits; they empowered individuals to pursue new opportunities and personal success.

“By making training and skills development accessible, we can help people upskill themselves and stand a better chance of escaping poverty.”

The dialogue also called for collaboration among students, educational institutions, and public-private partnerships to bridge the skills gap effectively.

Phumo urged students to align their educational choices with market demands and pursue internships and apprenticeships to enhance employability.

As the nation faces the dual challenges of economic stagnation and high unemployment, the call for a renewed focus on skills development resonates deeply.

Phumo’s vision for a South Africa built on a foundation of skilled artisans and professionals presents a pathway to not only combat poverty, but also drives innovation and economic growth. The dialogue served as a vital platform for discussing the importance of skills-based education as South Africa seeks to navigate its current crisis and build a more prosperous future for its citizens

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johnathan Paoli

The country’s education system must urgently be reshaped to better equip young people for the challenges of the modern economy, according to Higher Education and Training Deputy Minister Buti Manamela.

“The measure of our collective success is preparing young people to participate meaningfully in society,” he told an Inside Education and Sibanye Stillwater skills development dialogue on Thursday.

The event held under the theme “Reimagining Education for a Better Future” was held at the University of Johannesburg. It brought together prominent figures and stakeholders from the education sector.

Manamela underscored the integral role of education and vocational training in the National Development Plan (NDP), stating that quality education was the cornerstone of economic inclusion and employment opportunities.

Highlighting the importance of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) Colleges, Manamela expressed his personal commitment to these institutions, which he believed could play a pivotal role in addressing the skills gap in the labour market.

“By 2030, we aim for 2.6 million students to benefit from TVET Colleges, engaging in skills training that aligns with the demands of the economy,” he said.

The deputy minister discussed ongoing initiatives, including the rollout of Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR) Centres of Excellence across 16 TVET Colleges, aimed at providing students with advanced skills relevant to a rapidly evolving job market.

“These centres will serve as crucial platforms for collaboration among various stakeholders, including Sector Education and Training Authorities and TVET institutions,” he told the gathering.

As part of the discussion on embedding skills-based education from the foundational phase, Manamela reflected on the recent basic education lekgotla, where strategies were shared on equipping learners with essential skills for the future.

He acknowledged the need for early exposure to career options.

“Career guidance should begin as early as primary school, fostering awareness of vocational pathways among young learners,” he said.

In recognising the challenges faced by youth who were not in employment, education or training, Manamela urged communities to rally together to reintegrate them into educational and training frameworks.

He emphasised the importance of community-driven initiatives, such as the recently observed Community Education and Training month, which aimed to reconnect young people with educational opportunities.

The dialogue also celebrated the Decade of the Artisan, marking 10 years of collaboration between the Department of Higher Education and Training and the Basic Education Department.

This initiative has expanded access to skills-based training and awareness of artisan careers for young people.

Manamela reiterated the NDP’s vision for improved educational and economic opportunities for youth, saying: “In the 21st Century, young people deserve a chance to thrive amidst both unprecedented opportunities and risks.”

The event served as a call to action for all stakeholders in the education sector to work together towards a future where quality education was accessible to all, ultimately paving the way for a more inclusive and productive society.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johnathan Paoli

Higher Education and Training Deputy Minister Buti Manamela will deliver the keynote address at an upcoming skills development dialogue hosted by Inside Education, in collaboration with Sibanye Stillwater and the University of Johannesburg (UJ).

The event, themed “Reimagining Education for a Better Future”, aims to explore the integration of skills-based learning within the country’s education system.

Scheduled for Thursday, the dialogue will examine how skills-focused education can be introduced early in the learning journey, starting from Early Childhood Development and foundational phases.

This initiative is crucial as the country grapples with high unemployment rates, particularly among the youth.

The Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) sector has emerged as a key player in addressing this issue, providing pathways to employment and economic stability.

Manamela said that by embedding skills-based learning into the education framework from an early age, the country could equip its students for the demands of the job market and unlock socioeconomic opportunities.

He emphasised the importance of collaboration among various educational stakeholders to foster a system that prioritised practical skills and competencies.

The dialogue will feature three expert panels comprising curriculum developers, ECD specialists, education policymakers and representatives from TVET institutions.

Together, these experts will engage in discussions aimed at formulating actionable strategies to enhance skills education in South Africa.

In addition to Manamela, the event will also be attended by Basic Education Deputy Minister Reginah Mhaule, Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi, and UJ Vice-Chancellor Letlhokwa Mpedi.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johnathan Paoli

The KwaZulu-Natal education department has declared its preparedness for the upcoming 2024 National Senior Certificate (NSC) exams, with MEC Sipho Hlomuka outlining extensive work that has been done to ensure there are no issues.

He told reporters on Wednesday that this year’s examinations would see a total of 172,433 full-time candidates and 18,019 part-time candidates participating across the province.

The MEC outlined the scale of the logistics, noting that KwaZulu-Natal has the largest examination system in the country.

With 6343 invigilators overseeing sessions in 6710 examination rooms, the province is implementing a meticulously organised distribution plan for exam materials, utilisng 13 nodal points and 103 distribution centres.

A staggering 120 question papers will be printed, amounting to 30 million copies.

Reflecting on the success of the previous year, Hlomuka expressed pride in KwaZulu-Natal’s achievement as the second-best performing province in the country during the Class of 2023 results.

The department has set ambitious targets for 2024, aiming for a pass rate of at least a minimum of 90%.

It was 84.4% last year.

Hlomuka emphasised the importance of maintaining high education standards.

“As a province, we always say that our aim and target is to pass all candidates who sit for the final exam…,” he said.

To support this goal, the department introduced the 2024 Academic Improvement Plan at the start of the year.

Each of the 12 districts has developed localised plans to enhance student performance, particularly focusing on schools that previously scored below 40%.

The MEC highlighted various initiatives undertaken to prepare learners, including the Winter Classes Programme held in July, which provided nearly 99,000 pupils with additional tuition.

Upcoming weekend sessions aim to further support matriculants in their final preparations.

“Marking of the examinations will begin on December 1 and conclude on December 10,” Hlomuka said.

He outlined the logistical efforts involved, which included 32 marking centres and thousands of markers and support staff.

Results will be released in January next year.

Hlomuka also announced plans for a pledge signing ceremony on 18 October, where candidates would commit to upholding the integrity of the examination process.

This initiative is part of a broader effort arosss the country to ensure credibility and transparency during the examination period.

The MEC also expressed his gratitude to educators, organised labour and all stakeholders involved in the process for their unwavering commitment to student success, and urged parents and the community to rally behind the Class of 2024,

Meanwhile, the Democratic Alliance in the province has called for caution in light of the optimism expressed by the MEC.

DA education spokesperson Sakhile Mngadi said that while his party’s state of readiness tour expressed certain hopes, oversight inspections at the Ilembe schools have revealed little to no change at the district’s worst-performing school in 2023.

He said this was due to little assistance by the provincial department to date and having had no permanent principal since July.

He said his party will escalate its findings at Sabuyaze Secondary School to Hlomuka and his department as a matter of urgency in a bid to assist wherever possible ahead of the NSC exams.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johnathan Paoli

One of Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube’s priorities is eradicating pit toilets in schools, which continue to be a hazard and claim the lives of pupils

Gwarube told the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) that around 4000 pit toilets have been identified nationally, with just over 200 remaining as of now.

She emphasised the government’s commitment to clearing this backlog by March 2025, and reiterated that no child should be subjected to unsafe sanitation conditions.

“Eradicating pit toilets is one of my top priorities. We have completed 527 projects aimed at replacing inappropriate toilets, with another 581 projects are in progress,” Gwarube said.

The minister acknowledged that while new toilets had been built, some remained unsealed, posing ongoing safety risks.

She was speaking during the NCOP’s social cluster question and answer session on Tuesday.

On budget cuts in basic education, Gwarube pointed to the broader economic context, which included substantial debt servicing and a history of corruption draining resources.

She made it clear that while education remained a critical area of focus, the constraints on funding were severe.

“Each province has immense power over how they allocate their budgets. We can recommend, but the final decisions rest with them,” she explained.

Gwarube reassured the NCOP that no teachers would be retrenched despite the ongoing budget cuts, but acknowledged that provinces might opt not to fill certain posts.

The minister also addressed concerns regarding underperforming infrastructure projects and the role of implementing agents, expressing frustration over repeat offenders who failed to meet contractual obligations.

“We are adopting a zero-tolerance approach to shoddy work,” she asserted, indicating plans to blacklist non-compliant providers.

Gwarube confirmed that an independent audit of school sanitation facilities would be undertaken to ensure transparency and accountability.

The government aims to create a real-time data system to monitor progress effectively.

Looking ahead, Gwarube expressed a strong commitment to collaboration with provincial education departments, stressing that while she could not instruct provinces, she was actively working to facilitate improved outcomes.

“It’s essential that provinces use their allocated funds effectively, particularly for infrastructure development,” she noted.

As the minister concluded her address, she reaffirmed her dedication to improving the educational landscape in the country, underscoring that the challenges faced were dynamic and required ongoing vigilance and adaptability.

The session highlighted the urgent need for reform and a commitment from the department to address both infrastructural and systemic challenges, ensuring that the rights of every learner to safe and dignified education were upheld.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johannah Malogadihlare

The community of Naledi in Soweto is utterly devastated following the deaths of four children who are suspected to have died from food poisoning.

Gauteng education MEC Matome Chiloane confirmed that three children were from Karabo Primary School and one from Khauhelo Primary School.

“According to information at our disposal, a Grade 1 boy, a Grade 2 girl and a Grade 3 boy from Karabo Primary School sadly passed away on Sunday…. While a Grade 1 boy learner from the school remained in ICU at a local medical facility,” Chiloane in a statement.

A grade 2 boy from Khauhelo died on the same day after allegedly consuming snacks purchased from a spaza shop in Naledi.

It is believed that they ate chips.

Police are still investigating the matter, and the department has provided counselling to the learners, educators and family members affected by the incident. Gauteng Premier Panyaza Lesufi is expected to visit the families of children on Tuesday.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Akani Nkuna

Ntombozuko Mkizwana, crowned as South Africa’s new best teacher at the 2024 National Teaching Awards, has urged educators to rise above adversity and pursue excellence and exceptional performance.

After being named as the winner of National Best Teacher Award, Mkiizwana told Inside Education that teachers must strive to overcome obstacles and not allow their backgrounds to define or confine them.

“In our corners, we are all blessed teachers, but what is important is to go beyond the call of duty. Go beyond the prescripts of the curriculum assessments policy statement,” she said.

Mkizwana’s upbringing was marked by humble beginnings in the rural Eastern Cape village of Marombe, Katkop, where she was born into a family of seven. She had a simple but challenging childhood, walking long distances to school barefoot and
living in modest circumstances.

But she managed to rise above her difficult circumstances.

Mkizwana said was excited at the recognition bestowed on her at the National Teaching Awards in Ekurhuleni over the weekend, but dedicated her academic success to the village teachers who saw her potential and pushed her to excel
beyond the limitations of her underprivileged background.

“I am a product of a village education where my only beacon of hope was my teachers,” she said.

She wanted to study law, but teaching became a calling. Drawing from her own inspiring educators, Mkizwana was determined to shape young minds.

“After I qualified to teach, I fell in love with the impact and difference I was making in the lives of my learners, and my teaching with inspiration grew drastically,” said Mkizwana.

Her teaching journey began in 1997 at Balizulu Junior Secondary School, where she taught English to Grades 4 to 6.

Her career took an exciting turn in 2014 when she was handpicked to join the newly established Mandela School of Science and Technology in Mvezo, Nelson Mandela’s birthplace. Today, she proudly serves as the school’s deputy.

“Education is the centre of any development in the country. It is also important to ensure that teachers are making the difference. Because it is the difference that they are contributing that will make the sector open other horizons for us to excel as teachers,” she said. 

She outlines her mission as cultivating compassionate leaders equipped with values and confidence who defy rural-urban education stereotypes.

“My experience in dealing with learners is not just teaching for compliance – I am shaping global citizens, and I always have a strong commitment and drive to overcome the barriers of race and the socioeconomic backgrounds of the learners,”
she said.

Her teaching extends beyond the English classroom; Mkizwana has made a lasting impact as a multifaceted educator, excelling as a researcher, community builder, mentor and leader in her school communities.

“No matter how much teachers try to teach other subjects, without ensuring that a child gets quality teaching in languages, all those efforts will be in vain,” she said.

Mkizwana has called for language developmental programmes to be enhanced so that they directly impact the National Development Plan Vision 2030.

“We ought to expand the horizon of learners, especially with co-curricular programmes, because it is through co-curricular programmes that we can see the realisation of the impact of languages,” she said.

Mkizwana says the hallmarks of a successful teacher are stimulating students’ intellectual curiosity through reading, presentation, discussions of current affairs, and promoting critical thinking and promoting effective argumentation.

She said her instructional strategy included a jigsaw approach to empowering all learners and promoting collective responsibility, inclusivity and language equity.

This ensured that each pupil’s unique strengths were embraced and their potential unfettered.

Mkizwana is no stranger to winning accolades for her work in improving education in the country, particularly for pupils in the rural areas of the Eastern Cape.

In 2016, she received top honours, earning the Provincial Award for Outstanding Secondary English Teaching and the prestigious National Teacher Award for Secondary English Education.

She represented the Mandela School of Science and Technology in Germany during the 2015 exchange programme, promoting cultural exchange through sports and dialogue inspired by the leadership of South Africa’s first democratic leader.

Through a non-profit initiative she established, Mkizwana provides free English literature lessons on weekends, impacting schools across the district and beyond and sharing best practices for improving student outcomes.

“My influence on shaping learners to become global citizens is shown by how some of them transcended beyond the barriers of poverty and are now working in China, Singapore, America, Kenya, Rwanda and Mexico,” she said.

Considering recent efforts to move from traditional teaching and learning to internet- based methods, Mkizwana said there were challenges associated with the endeavour to produce quality content and make it accessible.

She advised that it could be addressed by supplying devices specifically designed for education and establishing comprehensive management and maintenance frameworks to enable remote schools in rural areas to access quality learning resources.

“Matric alone without practical skills won’t save our sector; there is a need for the skills that were [not] in schools before. And also, progress is needed to mitigate the staggering drop in pupils reaching matric, as echoed by Professor Jonathan Jansen,” she said.

Mkizwana called for more resources for other forms of education to diversify the nation’s skills, particularly in arts, music, dance and drama academies for learners in rural areas.

“Motivate teachers to continue making a difference in their different corners despite the plethora of challenges they face,” she said.

“But most importantly, encourage them to participate in the National Teaching Awards because they are the light and the reason for the change we see in our county,” she said.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Johnathan Paoli

With the National Senior Certificate (NSC) exams starting later this month, the Democratic Alliance has accused the KwaZulu-Natal education department for not intervening at some of the worst performing schools in the province.

The DA is on a state of readiness tour across the province ahead of the critical exams which start on 21 October.

According to its provincial education spokesperson, Sakhile Mngadi, the delegation was seriously concerned about the effectiveness of interventions implemented by the department in addressing persistent issues affecting academic performance.

“After just one day of the DA’s tour, it is clear that issues around maintenance, crime, parent apathy and departmental support and strategy are at the heart of why some schools continue to underperform,” Mngadi said.

The DA’s tour has revealed significant challenges at some of the worst-performing schools in the Umlazi District.

During a visit to Witteklip Secondary School in Chatsworth, which recorded a dismal 47% pass rate in the 2023 NSC exams, the delegation identified a lack of parental involvement as a major contributing factor to students’ poor performance.

Principal Gopi Naidu reported that a recent parent-teacher meeting aimed at discussing academic progress was attended by only two parents out of 138 learners.

In addition, Mngadi said the DA’s visit uncovered serious management issues at both circuit and district levels, including corruption, misuse of funds, and irregularities in the promotion of educators and selection of school principals.

Parents Association of KwaZulu-Natal chairperson Vee Gani highlighted systemic corruption, alleging that principals have “bought” their positions for as much as R120,000, and that some School Governing Body members faced intimidation in decision-making processes.

The delegation then moved to Chatsworth Secondary School, where the impact of gangsterism and theft has severely hindered academic success, resulting in a 55% pass rate.

Despite a R3.5 million renovation project in 2017, the school has suffered from rampant theft, including the loss of all aluminium windows.

Principal Arthur Luckhan revealed that classrooms have been without electricity for over two years due to ongoing vandalism and theft of copper wiring.

Luckhan said with only 7% of students paying school fees, the school lacked the funds necessary for repairs, and many classrooms were unused.

Mngadi said the safety of educators also emerged as a pressing concern, with teachers feeling unsafe after hours, impacting their ability to prepare lessons effectively.

With only 11 permanent teachers remaining, he said absenteeism has become a critical issue, forcing the principal to take on teaching responsibilities himself.

Once a thriving institution with an enrolment of 1,200 and a history of 100% pass rates, Mngadi revealed that the school now struggled to retain even 400 learners.

The spokesperson said that the findings highlighted the urgent need for intervention from education MEC Sipho Hlomuka and the department in the lead up to the NSC exams.

He said his party planned on submitting a comprehensive report outlining the various challenges faced by these schools. It would also seek immediate solutions to improve teaching and learning conditions.

“The DA in KZN has consistently spoken about the good quality triad in education. This includes sound leadership at the apex, good parental involvement and well-built and maintained school infrastructure,” Mngadi said.

KwaZulu-Natal department spokesperson Muzi Mahlambi has said in the past that despite the department doing everything in its power to improve conditions for learners, criminal activity had a severe impact on schools.

Asked to comment on the DA’s report on the state of schools, he said that the MEC would brief the media on Tuesday on the state of readiness of the province to hold the NSC exams.

INSIDE EDUCATION

By Edwin Naidu

A recent briefing on the state of governance of higher education institutions in South Africa, particularly focusing on the role and responsibilities of university councils, presents a balanced view, highlighting both commendable practices and areas for improvement.

The Portfolio Committee on Higher Education requested an update on governance in the tertiary sector following a meeting in November last year.

At the time, tensions at several institutions were on the agenda.

This time though, university councils came under sharp focus, with discussions focusing on strategic leadership, core functions, resource management and transformation.

Areas of concern included the lack of uniformity in inducting new council members, the absence of vice-chancellor performance evaluation systems in some institutions, and failure to submit annual and financial reports by some institutions.

Other issues included recurring race-related incidents such as those at Stellenbosch University, governance challenges and instability at several universities, and legal challenges to independent assessments and panel reports.

While the policy framework emphasises the need for safe and inclusive campus environments, several institutions face challenges in meeting these expectations.

Higher Education and Training Minister Nobuhle Nkabane also briefed the committee.

She stated that the student population has grown in the last few years, and the demand for student financing has equally increased.

However, the government was committed to addressing these challenges.

“This is because the government has created access to post-school education and training for the historically marginalised people of South Africa, especially for the children of the poor and the working class.

“Education is a critical tool the government uses to address historical injustices, poverty, and inequalities and equip students to enter the labour force as a driver to build a capable developmental state,” she added.

The challenges surrounding the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) were also discussed.

The minister said the NSFAS must be adequately prepared regarding resources and systems to meet this growing demand.

“Many students have expressed frustration over delayed payments and inefficiencies in NSFAS systems. Our constitutional democracy provides that the people shall govern, which means that the people must play a critical role in the country’s administration. We are committed to getting guidance from different role players in the PSET sector,” she said.

The minister reiterated that she extensively consulted with stakeholders in the Post-School Education and Training (PSET) sector to solicit input and proposals for policy positions on matters affecting the system.

She said a key goal was to increase the intake of the college system by targeting one million enrolments in community colleges and 2.5 million in public and private TVET colleges by 2030.

“About our universities, we will continue to diversify them based on their strengths and the needs of the communities in which they are located by targeting 1.6 million enrolments by 2030,” she said.  

“During these consultations, we have also reaffirmed our commitment to change the size and shape of our PSET system, particularly to expand the TVET college sector,” she said.

The department is also focusing on aligning the national skills need with curriculum content and looking at inputs regarding the review of some of the legislation and policies governing the sector.

Vice-chancellors from various universities, together with principals of TVET colleges also attended the stakeholder meetings.

“… their collective inputs will definitely help shape our policy positions and approaches to matters of teaching and learning and other areas of interest,” the minister said.

INSIDE EDUCATION